Journalist Sylvan Hardy who lives part time in Cuenca, Ecuador, is a former Southeast Asia news correspondent and columnist for several British newspapers.
On Sunday Jan. 29, Hardy published an interesting (and rather alarming) piece at the cuencahighlife.com website, where he explains why U.S. expats are also at risk of Trump’s immigration policies.
Three members of the Mexican Congress have an answer to U.S. President Donald Trump’s funding plan for his wall on the southern U.S. border.
If Trump applies taxes to Mexican imports to the U.S. or to remittances sent home by Mexicans living in the U.S., the congressmen say they will introduce legislation to confiscate property owned by U.S. citizens in Mexico. A less draconian option, they say, is to attach liens to the property to repay the government for losses from the Trump taxes.
U.S. citizens — not counting U.S.-based corporations — own an estimated $20 billion in Mexican real estate.
On Saturday, one of the Congressmen said the measures could also be applied if Mexicans living in the U.S. are “treated badly” as a result of new immigration policies. He suggested that the Mexican government could review the immigration status of all U.S. citizens living in Mexico, estimated to be between 600,000 and 800,000.
The news of the past week has offered voluminous coverage of the impact immigration changes will have on foreigners living in the U.S., both those with visas and those without. Entirely off the radar, however, is the impact those changes could have on U.S. expats, particularly those living in Latin America.
There are good reasons for the U.S. to revise its immigration policies and there is nothing wrong with Trump moving forcefully to make changes. Other recent administrations have dodged and jerry-rigged the policies for generations.
On the other hand, Trump’s bungled executive orders are nothing more than a PR freak show. What we have is the Trump Doughboy galumphing across the international media stage, dancing an idiot’s jig, waving his orders in air as holy writ. Although judges have already reversed parts of the orders and more reversals will certainly follow, the uproar they have stirred is only a precursor of what’s to come.
There will be bad blood and it will affect expats.
Of expats living in Latin America, those in Mexico certainly have the most to fear. If taxes are applied that damage the Mexican economy, and if hundreds of thousands of Mexican nationals are deported from the U.S., it is inevitable that U.S. citizens living in Mexico will become a major issue. Whether they will be subject to new immigration standards and costs or just to the anger of locals hurt by U.S. policy, remains to be seen.
Expats in Ecuador are in far better shape than those in Mexico and are far less likely to become pawns in geopolitical gamesmanship. President Rafael Correa is a vocal advocate for a “world without borders” and, for better or worse, Ecuador has one of the world’s most liberal policies on entry of foreigners into the country. Its policy on visas and foreign residency is also one of the most lenient.
U.S. expats in Ecuador will face far less anger from their neighbors as immigration rules are toughened. As Ecuador’s foreign minister points out, the vast majority of Ecuadorians in the U.S. live in “sanctuary” states and cities that offer a higher degree of security from new federal policies. Although Trump has signed an executive order to freeze funding to sanctuary governments, the issue will be in court for years (click here, to read more).
It will be weeks, probably months, before the full extent of Trump’s immigration changes are known and it is foolish to speculate on their full impact on expats. Suffice it to say that there will be an impact.
About the Author
Sylvan Hardy divides his time between Cuenca (Ecuador), the U.S. and Ethiopia. He is a former Southeast Asia news correspondent and columnist for several British newspapers.
7 Reactions on this Article
EVERYBODY is at risk when any country installs unstable leaders as well as hate and fear mongers.
Should Mexico do any of the above, they would forever ruin the reputation of the country as a place where people from all over the world can invest in property and support local economies. Mexico would need its own unhinged leaders to do that.
All the writer above is doing is spreading FEAR that may already chill folks from coming here an investing. The YT should do a better job about placing the articles of fear merchants who may have a secret agenda.
Damage is already being done in the U.S.and Mexican relationship; however, if Trump’s foolishness continues, all it will take is a spark, and all hell could break lose. Trump is pushing it. The Mexicans are holding back now, but watch out. They haven’t forgotten how they have been treated by the U.S. in the past, and now too.
The Mexicans are not as crazy, stupid, fearful and violent as the Americans have become.
They will mostly realize that Americans just don’t matter anymore.
I doubt that there enough Mexicans wealthy enough to pay the prices US Expats are paying for their homes. In addition, the billions of dollars we bring into the country annually would all go away. Mexico does not want a confrontation with the US, but the blithering idiot to the north is out of control. I would happily sign and circulate a legal document to demand impeachment of Trump in order to show my support of the Mexican people and their government. Additionally, I hold a Permanente card and will be applyling for citizenship. If you are an expat, I recommend that you do the same.
Jim first insults Mexicans by claiming “they aren’t wealthy enough” to buy their own houses. Then he makes an unsubstantiated claim about “the billions of dollars we bring into the country”.
It’s that kind of misleading and bigoted thinking that should make Mexicans move away from anything ‘American’.
It might be worth considering the source of this article. Cuenca High Life is the online newspaper of the expat community there, which is definitely promoting itself as THE Latin American destination for U.S. retirees, and seems to see itself in competition with other countries such as Mexico. There have already been previous articles published there suggesting that Mexico is an unsafe place for Americans; for example, when one expat was killed in a carjacking in Guadalajara, and one other was victim of a home-invasion somewhere else in Mexico, that same publication published a somewhat-gleeful news story suggesting that expats in Mexico would soon be streaming to Ecuador in record numbers for their own safety.
You’re correct James. Looks like the YT got hoodwinked.
Leave a Comment